| S/L | Criteria | KATALOX LIGHT | BIRM | Green Sand Plus |
| 1 | Operating pH | 5.8 – 10.5 | 6.8-9.0 | 6.2 – 8.5 |
| 2 | Filtration Level | <3 Micron | Not act as Filter | Not act as Filter |
| 3 | Iron Removal | Up to 100 ppm | Very Limited | Very Limited |
| 4 | Mn Removal | Up to 20 ppm | Very Limited | Very Limited |
| 5 | Arsenic Removal | Possible | Not Possible | Not Possible |
| 6 | No of Filter (Vessel) Required | Possible of Stand-Alone Treatment ( Work as Multigrade and Carbon Media Also) |
Multigrade and Carbon Filter Required | Multigrade and Carbon Filter Required |
| 7 | Area Required | Less Area Required | More then Katalox Light | More than Katalox Light |
| 8 | Operating Cost | Less | Higher | Higher |
| 9 | Compressed Air Requirement | Not Required | Required for Scouring During Backwash | Required for Scouring during Backwash and Oxidation |
| 10 | Regeneration | Not Required | Not Required | Required |
| 11 | Backwash Time | 10 – 15 Min | 20 – 30 Min | 20 – 30 Min |
| 12 | Rinse Time | 2- 3 Min | 5-10 min | 5-10 min |
| 13 | Coating of MnO2 | 10% | 0.5% | 1% |
| 14 | Media Life Time | 10 year | 5 year | 5 Year |
| 15 | Color Removal | Possible | Not Possible | Not Possible |
| 16 | Turbidity Removal | Possible | Not Possible | Not Possible |